Election Day has come and gone. Across the country yesterday, Americans cast their votes for offices from President of the United States to dog catcher. Here in Pennsylvania, all 203 seats in the House of Representatives were up for grabs, as were half of our 50 Pennsylvania Senate seats (the odd numbered districts), all three row offices, 15 of 18 congressional seats and one of our two U.S. Senate seats. Here’s how it all shook out.
New Members: Pennsylvania Senate and House of Representatives
Open Seats and Upsets: Who’s In and Who’s Out
Open Seats:
Going into yesterday’s election, we expected at least 21 new members of the General Assembly would take be elected to take office in January. We bid a fond farewell to four Senators and 17 House members this year, due either to their retirement from public office or their moving to a different elected office. Here’s who’s new:
Senate:
- SD-3 (Philadelphia): Sharif Street (D); retiring member: Shirley Kitchen (D)
- SD-13 (Lancaster): Scott Martin (R) defeated Greg Paulson (D); retiring member: Lloyd Smucker (R)
- SD-31 (Cumberland): Mike Regan (R) defeated John Bosha (D); retiring member: Pat Vance (R)
- SD-35 (Cambria): Wayne Langerholic (R) defeated Ed Cernic (D); retiring member: John Wozniak (D)
House:
- HD-31 (Bucks): Perry Warren (D) defeated Ryan Gallagher (R); retiring member: Steve Santarsiero (D)
- HD-45 (Allegheny): Anita Astorino Kulik (D); retiring member: Nick Kotik (D
- HD-49 (Washington): Bud Cook (R) defeated Alan Benyak (D)); retiring member: Pete Daley (D)
- HD-58 (Westmoreland): Justin Walsh (R) defeated Mary Popovich (D); retiring member: Ted Harhai (D)
- HD-92 (Cumberland): Dawn Keefer (R) defeated Kate McGraw (KMI); retiring member: Mike Regan (R)
- HD-95 (York): Carol Hill-Evans (D) defeated Joel Sears (R); retiring member: Kevin Schreiber (D)
- HD-101 (Lebanon): Frank Ryan (R) defeated Lorraine Scudder (D); retiring member: Mauree Gingrich (R)
- HD-106 (Dauphin): Tom Mehaffie (R); retiring member: John Payne (R)
- HD-111 (Wayne): Jonathan Fritz (R); retiring member: Sandra Major (R)
- HD-112 (Lackawanna): Kevin Haggerty (D) defeated Ernest Lemoncelli (R); retiring member: Frank Farina (D)
- HD-150 (Montgomery): Michael Corr (R) defeated Linda Weaver (D); retiring member: Mike Vereb (R)
- HD-158 (Chester): Eric Roe (R) defeated Susan Rzucidlo (D); retiring member: Chris Ross (R)
- HD-165 (Delaware): Alex Charlton (R) defeated Elaine Paul Schaefer (D); retiring member: Bill Adolph (R)
- HD-183 (Lehigh): Zach Mako (R) defeated Phillips Armstrong (D); retiring member: Julie Harhart (R)
- HD-192 (Philadelphia): Morgan Cephas (D); retiring member: Lynwood Savage (D)
- HD-200 (Philadelphia): Chris Rabb (D) defeated Latryse McDowell (R) ; retiring member: Tonyelle Cook-Artis (D)
- HD-202 (Philadelphia): Jared Solomon (D); retiring member: Mark Cohen (D)
- HD-203 (Philadelphia): Isabella Fitzgerald (D); retiring member: Dwight Evans (D)
Upsets:
We don’t typically see a lot of upsets in our elections here in the Keystone State, but with that being said, there are always a few surprises. Five incumbents lost their races yesterday, which brings five additional new members into the mix. Here’s who’s in and who’s out:
Senate:
- SD-15 (Dauphin): John DiSanto (R) defeated Sen. Rob Teplitz (D)
- SD-49 (Erie): Daniel Laughlin (R) defeated Sen. Sean Wiley (D)
House:
- HD-10 (Lawrence): Aaron Bernstine (R) defeated Rep. Jaret Gibbons (D)
- HD-51 (Fayette): Matthew Dowling (R) defeated Rep. Tim Mahoney (D)
- HD-115 (Monroe): Maureen Madden (D) defeated Rep. David Parker (R)
Welcome Back, Incumbents
One hundred and nine incumbents faced an opposite-party challenger yesterday; 104 of them won handily and will return to Harrisburg in January. A warm welcome back to:
House:
- HD-1 (Erie): Rep. Patrick Harkins (D) defeated William Crotty (R)
- HD-2 (Erie): Rep. Flo Fabrizio (D) defeated Pat Fuller (R)
- HD-3 (Erie): Rep. Ryan Bizzarro (D) defeated Greg Lucas (R)
- HD-6 (Crawford): Rep. Brad Roae (R) defeated Peter Zimmer (D)
- HD-8 (Mercer): Rep. Tedd Nesbit (R) defeated Judy Hines (D)
- HD-12 (Butler): Rep. Daryl Metcalfe (R) defeated Christian Rieger (D)
- HD-13 (Chester): Rep. John Lawrence (R) defeated Nancy Dean (D)
- HD-15 (Beaver): Rep. Jim Christiana (R) defeated Michael Rossi (D)
- HD-17 (Mercer): Rep. Parke Wentling (R) defeated Wayne Hanson (D)
- HD-20 (Allegheny): Rep. Adam Ravenstahl (D) defeated Jim Barr (Con.)
- HD-25 (Allegheny): Rep. Joseph Markosek (D) defeated John Ritter (R)
- HD-28 (Allegheny): Rep. Mike Turzai (R) defeated John Craig Hammond (D)
- HD-29 (Bucks): Rep. Bernie O’Neil (R) defeated Larry Mullins (D)
- HD-35 (Allegheny): Rep. Marc Gergely (D) defeated Fawn Walker-Montgomery (R)
- HD-38 (Allegheny): Rep. Bill Kortz (D) defeated Rob Salka (R)
- HD-39 (Allegheny): Rep. Rick Saccone (R) defeated Peter Kobylinski (D)
- HD-40 (Allegheny): Rep. John Maher (R) defeated Andrew Zahalsky (D)
- HD-41 (Lancaster): Rep. Brett Miller (R) defeated Nick Selch (D)
- HD-43 (Lancaster): Rep. Keith Greiner (R) defeated Steve Elliot (D)
- HD-46 (Allegheny): Rep. Jason Ortitay (R) defeated Joe Szpara (D)
- HD-50 (Greene): Rep. Pam Snyder (D) defeated Betsy Rohanna McClure (R)
- HD-52 (Fayette): Rep. Ryan Warner (R) defeated James Mari (D)
- HD-53 (Montgomery): Rep. Robert Godshall (R) defeated Leon Angelichio (D)
- HD-55 (Westmoreland: Rep. Joseph Petrarca (D) defeated Michael Geiselhart (R)
- HD-57 (Westmoreland): Rep. Eric Nelson (R) defeated Linda Iezzi (D)
- HD-60 (Armstrong): Rep. Jeff Pyle (R) defeated Gabe Lytle (GRN)
- HD-61 (Montgomery): Rep. Kate Harper (R) defeated Robert Wilkinson (D)
- HD-62 (Indian): Rep. Dave Reed (R) defeated Patrick Edwards (D)
- HD-63 (Clarion): Rep. Donna Oberlander (R) defeated Joseph Billotte (D)
- HD-64 (Venango): Rep. Lee James (R) defeated John Kluck (D)
- HD-65 (Warren): Rep. Kathy Rapp (R) defeated Troy Clawson (D)
- HD-70 (Montgomery): Rep. Matt Bradford (D) defeated Chuck Springer (R)
- HD-71 (Cambria): Rep. Bryan Barbin (D) defeated Mark Amsdell (R)
- HD-72 (Cambria): Rep. Frank Burns (D) defeated Cecilia Houser (R)
- HD-73 (Clearfield): Rep. Tommy Sankey (R) defeated Frederick Weaver (D)
- HD-74 (Chester): Rep. Harry Lewis (R) defeated Josh Maxwell (D)
- HD-75 (Clearfield): Rep. Matt Gabler (R) defeated Jay Notarianni (D)
- HD-76 (Clinton): Rep. Mike Hanna (D) defeated Stephanie Borowicz (R)
- HD-81 (Huntingdon): Rep. Rich Irvin (R) defeated Rick Rogers (D)
- HD-87 (Cumberland): Rep. Greg Rothman (R) defeated Jim Massey (D)
- HD-88 (Cumberland): Rep. Sheryl Delozier (R) defeated Christopher Cowan (D)
- HD-89 (Franklin): Rep. Rob Kauffman (R) defeated Christine Tolbert (D)
- HD-91 (Adams): Rep. Dan Moul (R) defeated Denise Weldon-Siviy (D)
- HD-96 (Lancaster): Rep. Mike Sturla (D) defeated Robert Bigley (R)
- HD-97 (Lancaster): Rep. Steven Mentzer (R) defeated Charles Klein (D)
- HD-99 (Lancaster): Rep. David Zimmerman (R) defeated Duane Groff (D)
- HD-100 (Lancaster): Rep. Bryan Cutler (R) defeated Dale Hamby (D)
- HD-102 (Lebanon): Rep. Russ Diamond (R) defeated Jake Long (D)
- HD-104 (Dauphin): Rep. Sue Helm (R) defeated Jody Rebarchak (D)
- HD-107 (Northumberland): Rep. Kurt Masser (R) defeated Michael Krankowski (D)
- HD-108 (Northumberland): Rep. Lynda Schlegel Culver (R) defeated John Deppen (D)
- HD-113 (Lackawanna): Rep. Marty Flynn (D) defeated David Burgerhoff (R)
- HD-114 (Lackawanna): Rep. Sid Michaels Kavulich (D) defeated Cheryl Scandale-Murnin (R)
- HD-116 (Luzerne): Rep. Tarah Toohil (R) defeated Gary Gregory (D)
- HD-117 (Wyoming): Rep. Karen Boback (R) defeated John Sweeney (Grn) and Louis Jasikoff (Ind)
- HD-119 (Luzerne): Rep. Gerald Mullery (D) defeated Justin Behrens (R)
- HD-120 (Luzerne): Rep. Aaron Kaufer (R) defeated Robert McDonald (D)
- HD-121 (Luzerne): Rep. Eddie Day Pashinski (D) defeated Betsy Summers (Lib)
- HD-122 (Carbon): Rep. Doyle Heffley (R) defeated Neil Makhija (D)
- HD-131 (Lehigh): Rep. Justin Simmons (R) defeated Joanne Jackson (D)
- HD-132 (Lehigh): Rep. Mike Schlossberg (D) defeated Ben Long (R)
- HD-133 (Lehigh): Rep. Daniel McNeill (D) defeated David Molony (R)
- HD-137 (Northampton): Rep. Joe Emrick (R) defeated Dave Mattei (D)
- HD-138 (Northampton): Rep. Marcia Hahn (R) defeated Daniel Richardson (Lib)
- HD-141 (Bucks): Rep. Tina Davis (D) defeated Drew Kreiling (R)
- HD-143 (Bucks): Rep. Marguerite Quinn (R) defeated Stephen Kunkel (D)
- HD-145 (Bucks): Rep. Craig Staats (R) defeated Vera Cole (D)
- HD-146 (Montgomery): Rep. Thomas Quigley (R) defeated Vera Cole (D)
- HD-147 (Montgomery): Rep. Marcy Toepel (R) defeated Rachel Hendricks (D)
- HD-148 (Montgomery): Rep. Mary Jo Daley (D) defeated Ed Flocco (R)
- HD-149 (Montgomery): Rep. Tim Briggs (D) defeated Chira Smith (R)
- HD-151 (Montgomery): Rep. Todd Stephens (R) defeated Jimmy Fagan, Jr.(D)
- HD-152 (Montgomery): Rep. Thomas Murt (R) defeated Albert Dermovsesian (D)
- HD-153 (Montgomery): Rep. Madeleine Dean (D) defeated Anthony Scalfaro (R)
- HD-154 (Montgomery): Rep. Steve McCarter (D) defeated Thom Estilow (R)
- HD-155 (Chester): Rep. Becky Corbin (R) defeated James Burns (D)
- HD-156 (Chester): Rep. Dan Truitt (R) defeated Carolyn Comitta (D)
- HD-157 (Chester): Rep. Warren Kampf (R) defeated Hans Van Mol (D)
- HD-160 (Delaware): Rep. Stephen Barrar (R) defeated David Cleary (Ind)
- HD-161 (Delaware): Rep. Leanne Krueger-Braneky (D) defeated Patti Rodgers Morrisette (R)
- HD- 162 (Delaware): Rep. Nick Miccarelli (R) defeated Jim Butt (D)
- HD-163 (Delaware): Rep. James Santora (R) defeated Barbarann Keffer (D)
- HD-164 (Delaware): Rep. Margo Davidson (D) defeated Inder Bains (R)
- HD-166 (Delaware): Rep. Greg Vitali (D) defeated Jim Knapp (R)
- HD-167 (Chester): Rep. Duane Milne (R) defeated Joe Denham (D)
- HD-168 (Delaware): Rep. Chris Quinn (R) defeated Diane Cornman-Levy (D)
- HD-169 (York): Rep. Kate Klunk (R) defeated Robert Marcoccio (NOA)
- HD-170 (Philadelphia): Rep. Martina White (R) defeated Matthew Darragh (D)
- HD-171 (Centre): Rep. Kerry Benninghoff (R) defeated Melody Fleck (D)
- HD-172 (Philadelphia): Rep. Kevin Boyle (D) defeated Jim Pio (R)
- HD-177 (Philadelphia): Rep. John Taylor (R) defeated Joe Hoenstein (D)
- HD-178 (Bucks): Rep. Scott Petri (R) defeated Neale Dougherty (D)
- HD-189 (Monroe): Rep. Rosemary Brown (R) defeated Damary Bonilla (D)
- HD-193 (Adams): Rep. Will Tallman (R) defeated Denise Van Essen (D)
- HD-194 (Philadelphia): Rep. Pam Delissio (D) defeated Bill Pounds (R)
- HD-199 (Cumberland): Rep. Stephen Bloom (R) defeated Jill Sunday Bartoli (D)
Senate:
- SD-5 (Philadelphia): Sen. John Sabatina (D) defeated Ross Feinberg (R)
- SD-9 (Delaware): Sen. Thomas Killion (R) defeated Marty Molloy (D)
- SD-17 (Montgomery): Sen. Daylin Leach (D) defeated Brian Gondek (R)
- SD-19 (Chester): Sen. Andy Dinniman (D) defeated Jack London (R)
- SD-25 (Jefferson): Sen. Joseph Scarnati (R) defeated Jerri Buchanan (D)
- SD-37 (Allegheny): Sen. Guy Reschenthaler (R) defeated Ed Eichenlaub (D)
- SD-41 (Indiana): Sen. Don White (R) defeated Tony Deloreto (D)
The state Senate is now comprised of 34 Republicans and 16 Democrats. Republicans picked up three seats.
The state House is now comprised of 122 Republicans and 81 Democrats. Republicans picked up three seats.
Let’s not forget—a handful of incumbents had their race tied up back in May, having faced a challenger only in the Primary Election. Those members, who enjoyed a low-stress election day, include:
Senate:
- SD-1 (Philadelphia): Sen. Lawrence Farnese (D)
House:
- HD-19 (Allegheny): Rep. Jake Wheatley (D)
- HD-24 (Allegheny): Rep. Ed Gainey (D)
- HD-37 (Lancaster): Rep. Mindy Fee (R)
- HD-79 (Blair): Rep. John McGinnis (R)
- HD-103 (Dauphin): Rep. Patty Kim (D)
- HD-175 (Philadelphia): Rep. Michael O’Brien (D)
- HD-181 (Philadelphia): Rep. Curtis Thomas (D)
- HD-182 (Philadelphia): Rep. Brian Sims (D) HD-190 (Philadelphia): Rep. Vanessa Brown (D)
- HD-195 (Philadelphia): Rep. Donna Bullock (D)
Three’s (Not) a Crowd: Row Offices
We’ve got three independent row offices in Pennsylvania- Attorney General, Auditor General and Treasurer-and all three were up for grabs yesterday. There was only one incumbent in the mix: Attorney General Eugene Depasquale (D) defeated John Brown (R) and will serve another four-year term as our fiscal watchdog. We’ll have a new Attorney General and a new Treasurer, though:
- Attorney General: Josh Shapiro (D) defeated John Rafferty (R)
- Treasurer: Joe Torsella (D) defeated Otto Voit (R)
D.C.-Bound: Pennsylvania’s Congressional Delegation
Fifteen congressional seats and one U.S. Senate seat were on the ticket yesterday; here’s who’s heading to the Federal City:
U.S. Senate:
- Sen. Pat Toomey (R) defeated Katie McGinty (D)
Congress:
- PA-1 (Philadelphia): Rep. Bob Brady (D) defeated Deborah Williams (R); Incumbent
- PA-2 (Philadelphia): Dwight Evans (D) defeated James Jones (R)
- PA-4 (Dauphin): Rep. Scott Perry (R) defeated Joshua Burkholder (D); Incumbent
- PA-5 (Centre): Rep. Glenn Thompson (R) defeated Kerith Strano Taylor (D); Incumbent
- PA-6 (Chester): Rep. Ryan Costello (R) defeated Mike Parrish (D); Incumbent
- PA-7 (Delaware): Rep. Patrick Meehan (R) defeated Mary Ellen Balchunis (D); Incumbent
- PA-8 (Bucks): Brian Fitzpatrick (R) defeated Steve Santarsiero (D)
- PA-9 (Bedford): Rep. Bill Shuster (R) defeated Art Halvorson (D); Incumbent
- PA-10 (Lycoming): Rep. Tom Marino (R) defeated Mike Molesevich (D); Incumbent
- PA-11 (Luzerne): Rep. Lou Barletta (R) defeated Mike Marsicano (D); Incumbent
- PA-12 (Allegheny): Rep. Keith Rothfus (R) defeated Erin McClelland (D); Incumbent
- PA-14 (Allegheny): Rep. Mike Doyle (D) defeated Lenny McAllister (R); Incumbent
- PA-15 (Lehigh): Rep. Charlie Dent (R) defeated Rick Daugherty (D); Incumbent
- PA-16 (Lancaster): Lloyd Smucker (R) defeated Christina Hartman (D)
- PA-17 (Northampton): Rep. Matt Cartwright (D) defeated Matt Connolly (R); Incumbent
Constitutional Query: Judicial Retirement Age
It’s no easy feat to amend the Pennsylvania Constitution; the proposal has to pass the General Assembly twice and then be put to the electorate for ratification. Yesterday, voters in the Keystone State were asked whether or not the mandatory age of retirement for our judges and justices should be raised from 70 to 75. The question passed by a vote of 50.88 percent to 49.12 percent.